Course Recap
During the beginning of class, I asked you to think about ways that Dr. Seuss’ The Lorax and Shel Silverstein’s The Giving Tree might represent their author’s attitudes regarding humankind’s relationship to nature. In terms of similarities, some of you noted that there is evidence in both texts that materialism and greed might be at the root of environmental decay; in terms of differences, some of you suggested that Dr. Seuss provides a more hopeful ending because the young boy accepts the responsibility of planting the truffala seed, whereas the old man in The Giving Tree has depleted the tree’s ability to regenerate itself. Others of you noted that the Lorax, who terms himself “the voice for the trees,” does not willingly give of his bounty and provides the Once-ler with a number of opportunities to change his ways, whereas the tree seems glad to give, for as long as she has something to give, and there is no concrete voice warning the young boy or his adult self of the potential dangers inherent in the way he is using nature. I suggested that the line “The tree was happy…/but not really” might be interpreted as a veiled critique, but if so, it is not given with the sort of direct focus found in Seuss’ text. Finally, I noted that while Silverstein’s text allows for multiple and even contradictory interpretations, Dr. Seuss’ text is a straight-forward morality tale.
During the second part of class, I asked you to locate scenes in both The Arrival and The Three Pigs in which significant events occurred – this gave you a chance to reiterate the postmodern elements of Wiesner’s text and the key points in the immigrant’s journey in The Arrival.
Homework
For homework, you should study for the exam on Tuesday and, if you have time, begin your reading for the fairytale unit. I know that facing the first exam for a new teacher is stressful, but if you use the study guide, review your notes, and practice writing out some responses, you should do very well on the test.
I noticed today that not everyone came to class with his or her books – be sure that for the exam you have access to all four picture books. I really, really made it clear at the beginning of the semester that I would strongly prefer that you own the books for this course – and I tried to keep costs low so that my expectations on this matter could be reasonably fulfilled. However, if some circumstance beyond your control or forgetfulness puts you into the position of not having one of the texts with you on Thursday, be sure to sit next to someone who is willing to share his/her text with you. You might also wish to use post-it-notes to keep track of page numbers, or write the numbers directly onto the texts.